Annular Lubrication on Deep Tunnels Under High Water Pressure

David Jackson, MBA
David Jackson, MBA
12 Min Read

What this covers

  • Why Depth Changes the Lubricant’s Job

  • The Filter Cake Is the First Line of Defense

  • Testing Against Water Pressure

  • Chamber Pressure Through Long Stoppages

  • Spewing and Water at the Screw Conveyor

  • Gas and Launch Seals

  • Line, Level and Settlement at Depth

  • Records That Pay off on the Next Deep Drive

  • A Checklist for Deep Drives

  • Where to Read More

  • The Short Version

Every meter of depth adds water pressure. On a shallow drive in tight soil, that barely matters. On a deep TBM drive or a long pipe jacking run below the water table, it changes how every fluid in the annular gap behaves.

If you design or run deep drives, the lubricant around the shield or pipe string is working against the groundwater the whole time. Here is what that means in practice, and what to look for when you choose a material.

Why Depth Changes the Lubricant’s Job

The lubricating layer only lowers friction while the pressure in the overcut stays above what the ground pushes back with. That support pressure keeps the cavity open and lowers the frictional stress on the shield or pipe.

As depth increases, the ground and the groundwater push back harder. A thin bentonite slurry is pressed into permeable soil, where pore water dilutes it and carries it away. The deeper the tunnel, the faster that happens.

Condition

What happens to a thin slurry

What it costs on site

Shallow, tight ground

Stays in the gap

Little

Permeable sand or gravel

Pressed into the soil and diluted

More pumping, rising friction

High water pressure at depth

Dilutes faster as depth increases

Higher thrust, settlement risk, water ingress

Long stoppage

Bleeds away while idle

Pressure loss and a hard restart

The Filter Cake Is the First Line of Defense

A filter cake is the thin, low-permeability layer a bentonite grout builds against the ground. It is what keeps water ingress out of the tunnel and holds the support pressure in the gap.

The problem with a thin slurry in coarse ground is timing. It bleeds into sand and gravel before the cake can form. A more cohesive bentonite-based grout holds its place long enough to build one.

When you compare products for a deep drive, ask how each one forms a filter cake in your soil, not just how slippery it is.

Testing Against Water Pressure

A constant pressure test is the most direct way to see whether a material will hold. A sample sits on a permeable bed under sustained water pressure for days or weeks, and you watch for leakage.

Results from one comparison show how wide the gap between materials can be:

  • Plain bentonite slurry leaked and was penetrated by pressure right away.

  • Bentonite slurry with additives leaked and was penetrated right away.

  • A stable bentonite-based grout held 5 bar for 31 days with no leakage.

In that test the grout sat on sand and gravel with a permeability of 2.36 x 10^-3 m/s and penetrated only 2 cm. Ask every supplier for results in the same format, on a bed that matches your ground.

Chamber Pressure Through Long Stoppages

Deep drives stop. Cutter changes, breakdowns and planned shutdowns all leave the machine standing in pressurized ground, sometimes for weeks.

While the machine stands still, two things go wrong at once. Friction builds against the shield or pipe, and the support medium bleeds into the ground. Soil squeezing is the biggest danger in a long stoppage, and the restart load can be far higher than the running load.

A material that stays in place helps on both counts. On one of the deepest TBM tunnels in the world, a 14.57 m slurry shield held 4.35 bar in the chamber through a 20-day shutdown with a stable annular grout around the shield. On the same drive, thrust force recorded on comparable rings was 15% lower with the grout than without it.

Field record

Result

Chamber pressure through a 20-day shutdown

4.35 bar held on a 14.57 m slurry shield

Thrust on rings with and without the grout

15% lower with it

EPB TBM with screw conveyor spewing in a fault zone

Spewing stopped within 1 day, air pressure held at 4.1 bar

Spewing and Water at the Screw Conveyor

On an EPB TBM, water-bearing ground can push water and soil out through the screw conveyor. Once that starts, the crew loses control of face pressure and the job can stop.

In one case, a 9.13 m EPB TBM met fissured, weathered sandstone and fault zones with low clay, inside the water table. Groundwater diluted the cement grout and polyurethane the crew injected, and the project was halted for 12 months. A stable bentonite-based grout stopped the spewing within 1 day, and air pressure held at 4.1 bar.

The lesson for design is simple. Materials that set or react can still be washed out before they do their job. A material that holds its shape in moving water has a better chance.

Gas and Launch Seals

Deep ground can carry gas as well as water. In an EPB TBM, a cohesive grout can form a barrier in the mud chamber so dangerous gas cannot enter the tunnel.

The same property helps at the portals. At launch and reception, the eye seal has to hold against groundwater while the machine passes through. Ask how a material performs at both ends of the drive, not only along it.

The field record here is encouraging. On an 11.64 m TBM launching into an artesian aquifer under a major river, a stable bentonite-based grout sealed the portal with only a fraction of the traditional fill, in half a day, and no leakage was seen after the first ring. On another drive, there was no water leakage at either the launch shaft or the reception shaft. A launch seal is where many deep drives first meet high water pressure, so it is a fair early test of any material you plan to rely on for the rest of the drive.

Line, Level and Settlement at Depth

Deep drives often pass under things that cannot move: rivers, rail lines, airports and other tunnels. A lubricant that leaves the gap does more than raise friction. It leaves a void the ground will close, and the surface feels it.

A grout that stays in place fills and supports the annular space, so the ground has less room to move. On one large rectangular pipe jacking drive under a sensitive city site, settlement stayed within plus or minus 10 mm, as designed, with a stable annular grout in the gap.

Density helps too. A denser mix, with a higher unit weight, adds buoyancy around the shield or pipe string. That helps the machine hold line and level, which matters most on long, deep drives where small steering errors add up over hundreds of meters.

When the alignment passes under something sensitive, write settlement limits into the lubricant section of the spec, not only into the monitoring plan. The material in the gap is one of the main tools you have to meet them.

Records That Pay off on the Next Deep Drive

Deep drives are expensive to get wrong, and most of the useful lessons are lost because nobody wrote them down in a usable form. A few records, kept the same way on every job, change that.

Log these against chainage and ground type:

  • Injection volume and pressure at the ports.

  • Thrust or jacking force per ring or per pipe.

  • Chamber pressure before and after every stoppage longer than a shift.

  • Any water ingress, spewing or gas readings, with the time they started and stopped.

At the end of the drive, write one page on what the lubricant did in each ground type and at each depth. That single page turns the next bid from a guess into a plan, and it gives you real numbers to put in front of a supplier when you ask for a comparison.

A Checklist for Deep Drives

Before you specify a lubricant for a deep or high-pressure drive, work through these points:

  1. State the water pressure at the deepest point of the alignment.

  2. Describe the soil at that depth, especially permeability.

  3. Plan for the longest stoppage you can reasonably expect.

  4. Ask for constant pressure test results on a matching bed.

  5. Ask for field records of thrust or jacking force and chamber pressure.

  6. Confirm the material pumps through your existing plant.

  7. Require supplier support at launch, when settings are made.

Where to Read More

A detailed look at how bentonite slurry and a stable grout behave under water pressure covers the pressure test, filter cakes and field results from deep TBM and pipe jacking drives. Product data for one lubricating annular grout for deep TBM drives is published by its developer, Balsam Laboratory.

The Short Version

Depth raises water pressure, and water pressure is hard on thin lubricants. The deeper the drive, the less room there is for a material that only works in the tank. Choose a material that forms a filter cake in your soil, holds pressure through long stoppages and stays in the gap when groundwater moves.

Test it under sustained pressure on a matching bed, ask for field records, and plan the stoppages before they happen.

Share this Article
Leave a comment